Versus

January 29, 2015
 

Godzilla vs. King Kong. vs. Pacific Rim

Versus 1

Ever since I was a child I have loved monster movies; I can’t put my finger on why but watching creatures beat the crap out of each other or stomping on cities is my happy place.

Godzilla (2014), King Kong (2005) and Pacific Rim (2013) are three of the biggest Creature Features of recent memory.

Big monsters. Big action.

But which of these three movies is really the King of the Monsters?

Let’s take a look and at the end you can vote for your favourite.

 

Pacific-rim

PACIFIC RIM

Guillermo’s del Toro’s Pacific Rim is a love letter to the Kaiju movies of old with big ass mech suits called Jaegers taking on even bigger monsters (Kaijus) from another dimension.

Although too much of the action takes place in the dark, there still manages to be a lot of colourful moments and monster punching action to make Pacific Rim a bit of a classic of the genre. The Jaegers are the stuff of 12 year old dreams and even grown-ups can sit back and enjoy the smashy smashy.

What this movie lacks though is heart and memorable human characters. The two annoying scientist dudes are meant to provide “comic” relief but you’re just hoping that they’ll get eaten or stepped on ASAP.

Our hero Raleigh Becket is played by Charlie Hunnam who can’t decide if he’s trying to do an American accent or not. After his brother is killed by a Kaiju in the opening battle sequence, Raleigh drops out of the Jaeger program and decides to join the rest of mankind building a wall which will do precisely nothing to stop the Kaiju invasion. That is until the scene stealing Idris Elba comes along and has one of the greatest action movie names ever: Stacker Pentecost. That’s just awesome! Anyway, he talks Raleigh into joining up and kicking monster ass once again and to round things up he gives one of the best “HELL YEAH!” speeches since Independence Day.

You don’t really care for any of the characters but really, with a movie like this you’re just wanting to watch Jaegers punch Kaiju in the face and we get that in spades. It’s well paced and doesn’t waste too much time on humans. It also has a satisfying enough conclusion with some spectacular action.

423b13dfbe5f7401dfa0f2110d348d18

KING KONG

With 2005’s King Kong, Peter Jackson demonstrated that he is unable to make a short movie. At nearly 3 hours long King Kong is certainly the most epic of the three films but it also has the most heart.

I really liked Adrien Brody and Naomi Watts in their respective roles but Kong is the only monster you actually care about. He’s tough because his environment is tough and he has to literally kill or be killed to remain King of the Jungle. When pesky humans come along and capture him, we know tragedy will soon ensue.

It was imperative that Kong be well realized so we can believe he is real and WETA did a fantastic job at making him as lifelike as possible. Andy Serkis is the mo-cap king and he really made Kong feel like a genuine character rather than merely a special effect. Not an easy task but they pulled it off.

Sadly a lot of the other special effects aren’t as good with a lot of Skull Island and its inhabitants looking very synthetic. The Brontosaurus stampede is unintentionally funny especially when they all start falling on top of each other; I’m not sure if that was meant to be hilarious but it was.

The movie is also about 45 minutes too long and there is far too much messing about in the first half.

Once we finally arrive at Skull Island though, this movie really kicks into gear and the build up to the King’s arrival is one of the best scenes of the movie.

I actually didn’t even mind Jack Black in this movie; it was nice to see him try something different where he isn’t just the “fat guy” making jokes. It really showed that he can genuinely act and you almost like him… until he captures Kong and we realize he is only interested in fame and fortune. He doesn’t really care about people at all and only wants to make the best film and get rich, no matter what the cost.

I think we all wipe away a few tears of manliness at the very end when Kong is being attacked by all the planes and plummets to his doom. “It wasn’t the planes, it was beauty killed the beast”… no, I’m pretty sure it was the planes and you humans taking him out of his natural habitat. Ah the arrogance of man…

Godzilla-2014-Weekend-Box-Office-We-Live-Film

GODZILLA

2014’s Godzilla promised us a much better film than the reviled 2008 Roland Emmerich movie and it was indeed better but sadly this is the weakest of all three movies we’re looking at today.

It takes over an hour before we actually get to see Godzilla and when he does fully appear he is either barely visible in the dark or the camera pans away to something else. It was an incredibly frustrating watch for me but it wasn’t without its moments. The HALO Jump scene into the city was rather ingenious and the movie tried to do something different with a formula we have all seen before.

I also thought the MUTO monsters were cool and the sound effects were awesome, especially in the scene on the bridge which really gave the creatures an otherworldly feel.

My biggest gripe (and pretty much everyone else’s) about the film though is the boring human lead, Ford Brody played by Aaron Taylor-Johnson; a man who appears to be more interested in chasing monsters than looking after his own family.

We were all hoping Bryan Cranston was going to be the hero and that definitely would have made the film more interesting but instead we got Aaron who just isn’t as interesting. His character is the blandest of all three of these movies and you will feel nothing watching it.

Godzilla himself looks great and there is a genuine sense of scale to the action, however unlike Kong he doesn’t have much personality. There are a few fun moments but I think it was definitely a missed opportunity.

 

THE VERDICT

For me, my favourite of the three movies is easily Pacific Rim; it’s not too long, has plenty of action and one of the best inspirational speech moments in years. Sure the characters aren’t that great but a monster gets hit with a ship… in the face and there is a real sense of fun to the action too so it’s easily my favourite, closely following by King Kong.

Now it’s your turn…


Who is the King of the Monsters?

Share Button


About the Author

Eoin Friel
Eoin Friel
I grew up watching JCVD, Sly and Arnold destroy bad guys, blow things up and spew one-liners like it's a fashion statement. Action is everything I go to the movies for and the reason I came up with this site is to share my love for the genre with everyone. We also want to help promote new talent whether you're making blockbusters, low-budget Indie movies or fan films; if it's action, it's awesome.



 
The Feed
 

 
the-protector-tony-jaa

Ong-Bak vs. The Protector

Tony Jaa made a name for himself as an exciting new force in martial arts movies with the action packed Ong-Bak & The Protector. We’ll ignore the sequels to both movies as none of them were particularly good but the o...
by Eoin Friel
 

 
 
casino-royale-0

Casino Royale (1967) vs. Casino Royale (2006)

Seeing as everything from The Crow to Commando is being lined up for the remake treatment in the coming months, it seems like a good time to have a look back over how other cinematic revamps have fared. In particular, it’s th...
by Eoin Friel
 

 
 
Donnie-Yen

SPL vs. SPL 2: A Time for Consequences

With the recent theatrical and VOD release of SPL 2: A Time for Consequences or Kill Zone 2 as it’s known in North America, I thought it would be the perfect time to compare them both and see which is the better movie. Th...
by Eoin Friel