Versus

January 9, 2017

Shanghai Noon vs. Shanghai Knights

It was announced a few months back that a third entry in the ‘Shanghai” series was in development with Napoleon Dynamite director Jared Hess in line to helm it; there is no word on whether the two leads (Jackie Chan and Owen Wilson) would return but it would be a pointless venture without them.

Anyway, it got me thinking that it had been a few years since I’d watched Shanghai Noon and Shanghai Knights so I figured now was a good time to revisit them and see what the better movie was.

Shanghai Noon (2000)

Hard to believe this movie is nearly 17 years old but after watching it again over the weekend I forgot just what a lot of fun it is. Owen Wilson and Jackie Chan make for a really likeable mismatched buddy duo and the action (as you’d expect from Chan) is never less than excellent.

The idea of a martial arts Western may have seemed like an odd idea at the time but for some reason it all just clicks and it’s mostly due to Wilson and Chan’s on-screen chemistry. Sure, Owen Wilson can be the same in the majority of movies but his easy going charm is just perfect for the lovable rogue Roy.

The role of Chon Wang is the kind that Chan can do in his sleep but this is a character that only he could play bringing his nobility, sense of honour and little bit of goofiness to proceedings. The good thing is the tone is just right which doesn’t descend into slapstick. The fights are excellent, although maybe not quite as exciting as some of Chan’s earlier work like Police Story but it’s always entertaining.

I forgot Roger Yuan was the main villain of this movie and he brings suitable menace to the role of Lo Fong and you can never go wrong with Xander Berkeley who plays the other villain (suitably named Van Cleef).

I think Shanghai Noon (and its sequel) are both a bit too long; at just under 2 hours you have to wonder if they could have trimmed a few moments and at times the script isn’t quite as sharp as it maybe could have been. There are still laughs to be had and Wilson especially has a few choice one-liners.

Shanghai Knights (2003)

The sequel to Shanghai Noon takes the action to London this time giving the movie a very different vibe from the first movie and frankly it’s not a welcome one. It no longer feels like a Western (which is what I loved about the first movie) and it’s really quite forgettable with little in the way of spectacular action scenes.

The main selling point for the movie though is one Donnie Yen as the main villain and he doesn’t disappoint. He has a decent fight with Chan for the finale but it is strangely underwhelming considering these are two titans of the genre. Aidan Gillen is always a fun villain and it looks like he had some serious sword training for this movie as his fight with Chan at the end was arguably more interesting than the one with Donnie Yen!

The script is rather poor to this one and I only cracked a smile once or twice; there were a bit too many lame moments like the Charlie Chan and Sherlock Holmes references. The British stereotypes were also hilarious but for the wrong reasons.

It’s all still harmless fun but I know which movie I prefer.

Verdict

For me this is an easy choice and Shanghai Noon is the far superior movie with Owen and Chan on sparkling form. Let’s hope they can rekindle that magic for Shanghai Dawn.



About the Author

Eoin Friel
Eoin Friel
I grew up watching JCVD, Sly and Arnold destroy bad guys, blow things up and spew one-liners like it's a fashion statement. Action is everything I go to the movies for and the reason I came up with this site is to share my love for the genre with everyone. We also want to help promote new talent whether you're making blockbusters, low-budget Indie movies or fan films; if it's action, it's awesome.




 
 

 

Tony Jaa & Donnie Yen XXX Featurettes

I was beginning to wonder if Tony Jaa was actually in this movie as he has barely been in any of the marketing but today we finally get a look at Tony in action as well as some more Donnie Yen. We’ll be seeing the movie o...
by Eoin Friel
 

 
 

Ashley Short: Action Actress, 2017 Demo!

Oh yes she is ready! Registered Nurse and all around kick ass action woman Ashley Short has unleashed her new action acting reel for 2017. Being a emergency room nurse is demanding on your time, yet offers in my opinion a uniqu...
by Dan Templegod
 

 
 

Hacksaw Ridge Blu-ray Details

Hacksaw Ridge was one of the best films of 2016 and I’ve been anxiously awaiting details of the home video release. Thankfully it’s only a matter of weeks as it will come to DVD and Blu-ray on February 21st. Sp...
by Eoin Friel